Tuesday 16 April 2013

Review of "The boy in striped pajamas"


The boy in striped pajamas, written by John Boyne, told how holocaust looked like from the point of view of a nine-year-old boy called Bruno. Bruno was the son of a Nazi officer but knew nothing about what his father was doing.  He made friends with a Jewish boy Shumel when his family moved to somewhere really close to the concentration camp. As a little boy, he misunderstood lots of the truth and let some of the evilness seem not serious in the book. The book used a boy’s naïve view to mock the evilness and show the truth to the audience. The book finally ended with the two young boys’ death and the SS officer’s crying. 
   When I read the book, my very first thinking is the book is ridiculous because the author seemed to make all the crimes unserious. Even though at the end of the novel, the SS officer seemed to realize his guilt, it was not enough at all. Rabbi Benjamin Blech described the book as "not just a lie and not just a fairytale, but a profanation". Despite the book's intentions, he argues, the plot is highly improbable and gives credence to the defence that people did not, and could not, know what was happening within the death camps.
    However, when I read it again last year, I found it irony, especially the ending. Like Kathryn Hughes said, "Bruno's innocence comes to stand for the willful refusal of all adult Germans to see what was going on under their noses". From a little boy’s sight, the world should be peaceful, colorful and beautiful. He may also be quite proud of his father since his father is his hero. Unfortunately, those crimes happened in front of Bruno's eyes. He cannot understand the truth as well as some really bad treatments his friend got. What happened in the world seemed like a game for the little boy but not for those who involved. The boy’s death told us who was killed in the holocaust --- the innocent people. Just like Bruno, those Jewish people who were killed were innocent. They did nothing wrong but got the terrible treatment and most of them even did not know they ere going to be killed when Thanatos coming.  In my opinion, the author was trying to blame all the people who saw the crime happened not only the Nazi party. Even a 9-year-old boy can see the crime and was involved in the crime, how can those adults and the whole society ignore the evilness? Boyne tried to blame everyone and the end of the book showed the regret of the Bruno’s father. But as we all know, the regret won’t help to solve anything.

6 comments:

  1. In this story, the contrast between innocence and guilt in such a significant historic time can be related and compared to the similar contrast in "The Reader".

    ReplyDelete
  2. It is for good reason that Bruno's father should be regretful, because everything that happened to his son was somewhat his fault. He could have tried to stop what was happening, but he didn't. If those things could happen to Jewish people, why shouldn't it happen to his own son? They are both human.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This is an excellent story. It strives people to ask questions and be emotionally torn between the two sides. The child in this story represnts a good moral conscious. One that has not been filled with greed or confusion. It shows a moral conscious of a child, of someone that we ought to be. It is easy to be persuaded by others but one must stick to his morals to remain humane in life

    ReplyDelete
  4. I enjoyed your overview of the novel. What i was wondering though because i also just recently read this book. Do you think John Boyne made Bruno more naive then he should have been. When i read this book i found that Bruno was oblivious to basically everything, and i just couldn't go along with that. I believe that kids are smart and would at least understand a little of what was happening at that time, especially when it would have been in the news everywhere. In the "Sound of Music" the main family in that story new what was going on in the world and they varied in age. I was wondering if i could get your opinion? also if you enjoyed this book, i think you would really enjoy the "sound of Music" it takes place around the same time frame, and focuses on a german family.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have really wanted to read this book, and this post has just made me want to read it more. I am very interested in the story behind it and how cruel society can be. It shows what should never be repeated. I like your view on the book and how the child is innocent and sees nothing wrong with the jewish people.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I loved this book! I too found it a bit odd how the father thought he was doing the right thing and didn't even realize his crimes. You can tell the mother does not like her husband doing this, but she doesn't speak up. I hate how clueless Bruno is to the whole situation. It really is irony that Bruno dies in the end.

    ReplyDelete